Okay, here's the scoop. Basically Jim and I were paying for a backup service on the server. This whole time we've slept secure knowing that if the drive ever died we would have a complete backup we could switch to. What we found out after the drive crashed was that this redundant backup had not been taking place.
Jim has been working like crazy to get this all worked out. The site should be back up later today, or maybe tomorrow. The server company is paying for professional drive restoration to see if we can pull the old data off the drive. One way or another, though, the sites will be back.
The one good thing to come out of all this is we'll be able to switch back to the main domain. Right-Thinking.com shall live again, and BlisteringCheese.com will go back to being the back door.
More info as it becomes available. For the time being, keep checking both domains to see when the site goes live.